Seems like a ludricous idea; after all, how can a government go bankrupt?  Well, according to this powerpoint presentation (which I’ve also provided in video form above), if administrative agencies and municipalities like school boards and entire towns can go belly-up, then so might a national government.  Consider also the recent troubles in Iceland.  Russia has come to their rescue, providing them a €4bn loan from the goodness of their hearts.  Time for a Mr. Rogers moment: “Can you say, ’satelite state’ boys and girls?  How about, ‘return of the Soviet bloc’?”  Of course, one has to wonder whether Russia, with its own earthshattering fiscal crisis, can really afford any financial adventures into the North Atlantic.

What I’m most curious about is what precisely a federal bankruptcy would mean.  Would it be a scenario like that which happens to a company, i.e., it will be restructured and recreated into something signficantly different?  If so, what happens to you and me, J.Q. Public, during the intervening limbo?  What would the new United States government look like, and how would it operate?  (Would it even still be a democratic republic?)

The apocalyptic picture is one painted by Michael Hodges, cumrudgeon author of the Grandfather Report, and John Rubino, the alarmist hack behind DollarCollapse.com, as well as Collapse of the Dollar and How to Profit From It and How to Profit from the Coming Real Estate Bust (very humanitarian titles, wouldn’t you say?)  Two years ago I corresponded with Hodges (Rubino wouldn’t return my e-mails).  We had a bit of an irascible back-and-forth, and I disagreed with much that he said.

Or would federal bankruptcy mean the slashing and burning of government-provided services and programs?  Again, if so, what happens to you and me down here, on the street?  I’m curious to hear everyone’s thoughts.

——————

A reader had this to say about my “presidential platform“:

Chris,

While I admire your willingness to put your views out there, I have to respectfully take issue with some of your statements, especially vis a vis the current financial crisis.  It seems to suffer from over simplification of the issues-a problem that seems to affect both right wing and left wing media.

Respectfully submitted,
-an independent.

Certainly, my take on the economics could stand for some nuance.  But when we consider (a) that the engine of the recession is the sweep of foreclosures on variable-rate mortgages, and (b) our political leadership’s complete lack of any attempt to address this problem, then I’d opt for the cold-water-on-the-face approach.  And while I appreciate the argument that “if the banks fall, we fall,” i.e., through the folding of small businesses and the consequential losses in jobs, fundamentally the Paulson plan is just a top-down solution to what is really a bottom-up problem.

Nevertheless, not-so-radical options may exist.  For instance, on October 2nd the Wall Street Journal ran an interesting editorial proposing a free-market solution to the mortgage crisis, and a friend suggested that having banks convert all variable-rate mortgages to fixed-rate mortgages might stabilize the plummetting prices.  Meanwhile, the BBC’s Robert Peston argues for a synchronized free-market global approach.  None of these would be cure-alls, but at least they would directly help the little guy as opposed to the more of the supposedly miraculous trickle-down effect.

3 Responses to “Can the United States government go… bankrupt?”

  1. curiouslyinspired said

    Hi Chris, Re “federal bankruptcy”, thinking out loud, I guess an important point is whether or not we have civil unrest accompanying gov bankrupcty. If the government maintains a measure of control then it might still be able to collect taxes as it sorts things out. If not, and anarchy takes hold, then we have utter mayhem and it might not be possible to reform anything and opening up the possibility of some dictatorship stepping in to take control. I am aware I am drifting off the original question though somewhat.

    Government debt will be defaulted upon (as it was in Russia in 1998). If the currency collapses – might not be able to import goods from abroad – shops will empty out of certain things we might be used to – like they are now in Iceland. Certainly internal spending programmes will be cut. There has been a recent precedent in the UK – when a local council went bankrupt, rubbish did not get collected for weeks, for starters, I am sure there was more grim stuff. I’d have to look it up.

  2. [...] of my posts, “Can the United States go… bankrupt?” and “If I were running for president,” have generated a pleasant amount of traffic.  [...]

  3. Yes the US Government can go bankrupt, once salaries are not paid to government workers, they just will not do their job. This happened in the Philippines and even led to a few coup attempts. My big question is what will happen when the millions on Welfare no longer receive their checks? The thefts and violence would increase causing the government to declare Marshal Law.

Leave a Reply